Presentation #1

Support for “step down heights” principle shown

Presentation #2

Parking at BART does not need to be replaced

2 stories over whole site is restrictive

Don't need to replace all the parking, hills residents can bus downtown

Good architectural style

There needs to be additional parking spaces, all low income housing

Not visionary enough


Presentation #7

Good mix of heights

Too much parking

Taller heights would allow for more amenities and open space

Not appropriate for neighborhood

Good balance between housing production (especially with the tower) and community needs, like access to open spaces

"Iconic restaurant" and tower not appropriate for residential neighborhood

The "transit village" is far too high, too dense, and too ugly

Yes, replace all 800 spots and add 100 more; "tower" suggestion wouldn't work for this neighborhood

Good focus on increasing the amount of housing available in the neighborhood in a realistic way


Presentation #8

Love that it connects to the greenway

Love that plan creates middle income housing

Focus on missing middle is important, but would be more appropriate for the surrounding blocks, which should be upzoned

Love mixed use and variety of forms

Love the style and scale of the buildings, "missing middle" is a great concept for this site

Should have more units than BART minimum

Appropriate variety of housing types

Could include 7 stories

Too tall

Not dense enough


Presentation #9

Oxford Plaza is great downtown, but too urban for North Berkeley BART


Presentation #11

Creative and realistic, we want more neighbors

Gorgeous rendering, but wrong scale for this site

Too tall

Good vision for a lot of housing and very different activities balanced with parking

Absolutely ridiculous

Blocks the view


Presentation #15

Needs to be great, but looks like status quo


Presentation #16

Too little housing, too much parking

Excellent scale, nicely shaped buildings, community meeting spot, good if limited to 4 stories,

Like view corridor.

Multi-modal access is important, no surface parking

One is the best designs, very thoughtful about use and emergency contingencies, must be sure to keep the view

Housing is more important than views of Mt. Tam

Focus on parking and open space is misguided, aiming to keep views of Mt. Tam isn't a high priority


Presentation #17

Most feasible of proposals

Replace parking with homes


Presentation #18

Interesting to pickup and drop-off


Presentation #19

Good traffic control

Greening whole site interesting but not sure if feasible

No building facades are a concern

Too much parking

Like the green space, but too tall

Like the idea of 2-3 stories, underground parking, and a path over the buildings

Can we offer housing units to people who don’t own cars? Create a carless complex, except for commuters who drive to BART

Like the large park 2 stories up; it's big, but not bulking


Presentation #20

Too short, new street?

Bikeway connection and access to vehicles from Virginia to Sacramento good idea

Non-starter; too high, huge, boxy, unattractive, no provision for replacing the needed parking it would displace, structurally impractical

Well done connecting Greenway


Presentation #22

Internal streets should be 15 mph or less, some 7-story height

I like the idea of private courtyards, but not sure they'd work out with the need for Ohlone open space

Fine print of "up to 8 stories" is not okay

No. Housing should be all low income, disabled, senior and not for students

Good focus on housing and good diversity of housing types


Presentation #25

Student housing poor choice

EVCs are invasive

Open space must be part of site

Too tall at the edges

Amazing idea that combines the life lessons of elders with the next generation responsible for a bright future

Good idea to continue Ohlone Greenway and integrate as much greenspace as possible


Good, thoughtful, students won't need cars, advantage of increased multi-generational community

Love the idea of natural + vegetation and a grove of native plantings

Like that there’s only one coffee shop and no other businesses


Presentation #26

Very thoughtful

Involvement of Ohlone a great idea

Architecture too repetitive